Practical answers from our team

Home Warranty or HVAC Maintenance Plan

A home warranty does not automatically pay the furnace repair you were quoted. In a video we published in November 2026, we explain who chooses the contractor, what a claim may approve, and how that compares with a maintenance membership from a company you choose. Read the contract before you buy.

The short answer
  • Check the contract before arranging a diagnosis. Many providers require prior authorization and use their own assigned contractor, and an outside diagnosis may not be reimbursed.
  • Filing a claim typically turns contractor selection and repair over to the provider, depending on the contract.
  • On warranty claims we have seen, the approved repair was limited to one failed part.
  • A maintenance membership does not make repairs free. Confirm the current visits, discount, and scheduling terms.

When the furnace quits, who chooses the contractor?

In a video we published in November 2026, Tucker Yarbrough explains what we have seen when a furnace fails and a homeowner tries to use a home warranty. We are Yarbrough & Sons Heating, Cooling & Plumbing, a family-owned HVAC and plumbing company in Blanchard, Oklahoma.

A home warranty is a service contract. Coverage depends on that contract. The manufacturer warranty that comes with the furnace is a separate document.

You should understand who the contract allows to do the work. With a home warranty, the company usually subcontracts the repair and assigns the contractor. Check the contract before arranging a diagnosis, because many providers require prior authorization and use their own assigned contractor, and an outside diagnosis may not be reimbursed. Filing a claim typically turns contractor selection and repair over to the provider, depending on the contract.

Some home warranties do pay claims. Whether yours pays still depends on the contract, the exclusions, and the claim process.

    On smaller screens, scroll the comparison sideways to see both options.

    Who controls the furnace repair
    QuestionHome warrantyMaintenance membership
    Who comes to the houseThe warranty company usually assigns or subcontracts the contractorYou choose the company
    What happens after diagnosisCheck the contract before arranging a diagnosis. Many providers require prior authorization and use their own assigned contractor, and an outside diagnosis may not be reimbursed. Filing a claim typically turns contractor selection and repair over to the provider, depending on the contract.The company you choose does the visits and the repairs you approve

    What a home warranty can cost when the furnace quits

    In a video we published on November 14, 2026, we gave examples of $30 to $50 a month, sometimes about $100 a month. Those recorded examples are what we gave on that date, not a current price for any plan. The contract may include a service-call fee, copayment or deductible, depending on the contract.

    In a video we published on November 14, 2026, we described one furnace repair we quoted at $586. In that recorded example, the home warranty company offered $284, which was less than our quote. The recording is our only source for the $284 amount; we did not independently verify the provider's offer. It is not a current quote.

      A one-part fix and a long exclusion list

      On warranty claims we have seen, the approved repair was limited to the one part that failed, such as an igniter or a sequencer.

      The contract can include many exclusions, and the company can deny a claim because of one of them. Read the exclusions and the rest of the contract before you buy. The contract you sign is what controls the claim.

        What our maintenance membership included in November 2026

        In a video we published in November 2026, we described our maintenance membership as two visits a year, one in spring and one in fall, a 20% repair discount, priority scheduling with a visit within 24 hours of the call, plumbing discounts, indoor air quality discounts, and filter changes. Those are the terms we described in that video. Confirm the current terms before you enroll.

        A maintenance membership does not make repairs free. If a repair is needed, you may still pay for that repair. You still choose the company that comes to your home.

        Our technicians and installers are background checked and insured. We are a licensed company.

          Questions to ask before you buy a home warranty

          If someone offers a home warranty while you are buying a house, ask who is offering it and whether that person is paid for the sale. Then read the contract.

          Ask how a claim chooses the contractor, what repair amount the company can approve, and which exclusions apply to a furnace. If you want a company you already know to maintain the system, compare that membership with the warranty contract before you pay.

          • Who chooses the contractor after a claim is filed?
          • What repair amount can the company approve, and does the contract include a service-call fee, copayment or deductible, depending on the contract?
          • Which exclusions apply to the furnace?
          • What do the current maintenance visits, discount, and scheduling terms include?

          Watch Our Team Explain

          The main recording plays below. Choose another recording, then select Play Video. Swipe the thumbnails or use the arrow keys to browse.

          Why Home Warranties Can Let You Down When Your Furnace Quits

          Video published

          Recorded prices, offers, equipment, and service details reflect the recording and may have changed.

          Professional demonstrations are not instructions to perform electrical, gas, refrigerant, or combustion work yourself. Leave that work to a qualified professional.

          Loading the video player…

          Watch This Video On YouTube

          Our Source Videos

          These original recordings contributed to this guide. Recorded prices, offers, equipment, and service details reflect the recording and may have changed.

          Why Home Warranties Can Let You Down When Your Furnace Quits

          Video published

          Watch The Original On YouTube

          Read The Source Transcript

          So, it's the coldest night of the year so far. You turn on your furnace and you're thinking, "Great. I'm going to get nice, warm, and toasty." And boom, nothing comes on. And you're left in the cold quite literally. But you think, "I have a home warranty. This is great. I don't have to pay anything." Wrong. They're terrible for your furnace. And I'm going to tell you exactly why. All right. I'm Tucker Yarro with Yaron Son's Heating, Cooling, and Plumbing. We are a family-owned and operated HVAC and plumbing business here in Blanchard, Oklahoma. We've done tens of thousands of HVAC and plumbing installs, and keeping your home comfortable is what we do. Let's talk about how a home warranty company is terrible for your furnace. So, what I mean by a home warranty company is bad for your furnace. Uh, so let's zoom out. Let's go like grandiose insurance at large, right? They only make money when they don't spend any money. And if your whole business model is I get to make money, I don't. I'm speaking as if I'm the insurance company. Bear with me here. If I get to make money only when I don't give you money that you have already paid in. Well, that seems kind of crossways. You live in your house. You own your furnace. You should be in charge of who is coming into your home to work on the thing that is the most expensive appliance in your home, which is your HVAC system. But with a home warranty company, here's the problem is you spend, I don't know, 30, 40, 50, sometimes $100 a month on this home warranty company. It's supposed to cover everything. It's this whole like beautiful idea of like, hey, you just pay this little bit amount and you don't ever have to worry about fixing your home's most annoying nuisances. It's the rental agreement for the homeowner thinking, I don't have to actually take care of this. You get the landlord treatment 101. That's what they pitch you. But the problem is is they send in somebody who's illqualified, undercertified, and driving a used truck that might have been a jilapy back in 1984. Rest assured, they're going to get it fixed for as little as possible so they can keep as much money as they want to. That's why it's bad for your furnace because if your furnace breaks down, if it comes to a large repair, well, one, if it's a large repair, the home warranty company a lot of times isn't going to use the most qualified company out there. So, they're not going to be really capable of fixing the problem. But two, if it's like, you know, a minor problem, well, minor problems are typical dominoes. They one thing starts, leads to another, leads to another, leads to another. And if a home warranty company sends a technician into your house, meaning they don't send a technician, home warranty companies just subcontract out the uh the HVAC companies, but if a home warranty company sends a tech out to your home, well, they're going to go and look for just the cause of that one problem. So, it's just going to be this one igniter. It's going to be this one sequencer. It's not going to look at the holistic issue at large. And so, what happens is is we go in, we fix it. Well, we fix it, we pay the, you know, home warranty company deductible if there is one, and then we move on. But then next month, what happens? all the furnace breaks down again because we didn't realize that the furnace is an interconnected system full of sequences and relays and uh you know it's basically a RP Goldburn machine. The fact that we have the capability to push a marble down and you know ding ding ding ding ding ding and then it causes your home to be comfortable is a miracle of miracles. But here we are. And so whenever we send somebody who doesn't look at the system holistically into your house or whose whole prerogative is, well, we need to charge as little as possible because again, home warranty companies only make money when they don't spend money. Well, then we are going to miss things that we should have caught in the first place. That's what I mean by it's bad for your furnace. So, there's this like gotcha moment as well is a lot of times home warranty companies are brought in on the front end of a real estate purchase. So, like you just bought your house, your realer says, "Hey, I got this great deal on a home warranty." Um, and fails to mention that they probably make some commission on selling you this home warranty. Uh, and so I get it if you don't know what you're selling. like if you're like if you genuinely think that this is a good thing for your homeowner that you're selling a house to, I can, you know, I can glaze over a little bit, but where I get a little bit frustrated is the disclosure side of it where it's like a realer might not disclose that they're getting a commission from this and ultimately um I have not met many uh realtors that we do work for that have a home warranty on their own house. So, that should say something. However, they do have a maintenance agreement. And that's where I go to next is on a home warranty company is basically you're trying to prolong the life of your system. You're trying to mitigate the repairs that you might have. And ultimately, you're trying to make sure that you get the most bang for your buck when it comes to your home comfort. And that's where I lean really hard onto a maintenance membership of some sort. So, at Yron Suns, the heritage maintenance membership that we have, it comes with a 20% repair discount. Two visits a year, one for the spring, one for the fall. You get priority scheduling, meaning you cut the line. So, we guarantee that we get out to your house within 24 hours of when you call. You get discounts on plumbing. You get discounts on IQ. You get filter changes. You get all the bells and whistles of, you know, kind of the comfort of knowing that, hey, this thing's taken care of. But none of the headache of not knowing who's coming to your house. And who is coming into your house matters a whole heck of a lot to me. And that's why all of our technicians, all of our installers are background checked, they're licensed, they're insured. to make sure that they're there on time, that they have the things they need in order to complete the job the way that it needs to be done. And that's where I lean super hard into maintenance memberships because ultimately it's the one and the same. The gotcha moment of the home warranty company is it sells you this comfort promise that you're paying a small amount that you don't have to worry about your home's most expensive appliances and that it's going to get taken care of. And in the best of cases, the home warranty stands. I know there's going to be a couple out there that tell me, well, I've had one for 36 years and Tucker's taken care of everything except for, you know, washing my dog on Sundays. And outstanding. Tell us who that is in the comments. Because every home warranty company that I've dealt with has ended up in one of the situations that I've discussed just a minute ago, which is we went out there, we diagnosed the system. Because you, the homeowner, you're going to get to choose who comes out to diagnose the system. That's where it's at. But then if you enact and say, "Hey, I want to use my home warranty company." Well, then now it's out of our hands as you know the company that you called out there in the first place. Well, now we're sidelined and they're going to tell you, "Hey, Mr. or Mrs. homeowner, the most we could offer for this repair that Tucker said that you need is going to be $284." Meanwhile, the repair cost that I quoted you was $586. And so, what they're going to do is they're going to go find the technician who's willing to do it for $284. And like I said, you know, the uh we we quoted often, which is the sweetness of low price wears off long before the bitterness of poor quality sets in. And frankly, I believe in that wholeheartedly. So, when it comes to who comes into your house and you being in control of it, I think that's where the maintenance agreement versus the home warranty company really comes into play because you can get the same benefit. You get the discounts. You get the choice. You get to make sure that you know who's coming into your house, but you don't get the uncertainty of, hey, is this thing going to be fixed the way that it should or am I going to get to make sure that I am comfortable with the person coming into my home? And that matters a whole heck of a lot to me and it should matter a whole heck of a lot to you. And I think that it probably does. So, the numbers of the home warranty game also kind of tell a misleading story. They are wrapped up in tons and tons and tons of lawsuits and litigations just like insurance companies because we sell this as a home warranty. It's not a warranty. It's a like appliance insurance policy which has I mean, I don't know if you've ever looked at an exclusion list, but guys, this is an exclusion list for a home warranty company right here. I'm just kidding. This is all of our scripts. But that is what it looks like whenever it comes to the exclusion list that a home warranty company has is, you know, it they're not going to fix it if the temperature outside is less than 40° and it's the third Saturday of October and your favorite football team just lost. And there's just a bunch of random exclusions in there that make it to where there's a way for them to get out of it if they want to get out of it. And frankly, I think that the contractors that you choose to come into your home should stand behind the work that they say that they're going to do. and a home warranty company who has an exclusion list as long as my arm shouldn't have the right to come into your house and tell you what they are or aren't going to fix. You've been paying in. You've been making sure that you're doing your part. And now they're all too quick to say, "Well, that's not covered under this exclusion." Like right now, there is, let me look down at the notes here. There's an active lawsuit of over 700 claimants in Southern California who have denials on their HVAC system for who knows it's a number of reasons, but we have another small class action lawsuit brewing because these home warranty companies have exclusions on the list. So, here's kind of what I want you to think of is you're doing your part. You're paying in monthly. You're paying $30, $40, $50 a month. That money should be better spent on a maintenance agreement with a company that you like, know, and trust that is capable of doing the same the things that they say they're going to do. And yes, I get it. If a repair happens, you probably still have to pay for that repair under a maintenance agreement. You probably do. But like with your Bronson, you get a 20% discount in priority scheduling to make that as painless of a process as possible. There's no such thing as a free lunch. And that's the exact same thing with the home warranty companies. They recognize that, too. That's why they don't make any money unless they don't pay out any money. And it's a Bassackwards business program. And it makes you uncomfortable in your home. Not only because your home's most expensive appliance broke down, but also uncomfortable in your home because maybe you don't know who's coming into your house and maybe you don't like know and trust who they are. And you should be in charge of that at all times. There should be no question as to who's coming into your house, why they're doing what they're doing, and what they're actually working on, and what you've approved. But guys, ultimately when it comes to making a decision for your home warranty or your maintenance agreement, obviously I can see the comments right now. I'm reading into the future. You're going to be like, "Tucker, you just want us to sign up for your maintenance agreement." Yes, you're right. I do. I want you to sign up for our maintenance agreement. I want you to have a maintenance agreement with a company who you like, know, and trust, and who's going to be here for 30 plus more years. Like I said, we've been in business since 1988. We've done tens of thousands of HBAC and plumbing installs. The home warranty company can't say that. This home warranty company I guaranteed was founded in 2012 right after some insurance check got cut to somebody who didn't know what the heck they were doing but they were really good at actuarial math. So they said we can go and ensure some appliances at the house. Guys, if you want to be in charge of who is coming to your house, if you want to be in charge of your comfort in your home, you need to make sure that you read the fine print, read the exclusions, and at the end of the day, if you find a home warranty company that you're like, you know what, Tucker, kick rocks, kid, because I trust these people. Outstanding. I want you to do what's best for your home. But what I found is most of the time a home warranty company is not going to be able to fulfill what is best for your home and your home comfort. Guys, other than that, do something nice for somebody. I'm out. Y these are the folks you should know. No need to sweat, no need to fret. Call 4853470.

          Keep Learning

          Homeowner Guide

          How to Choose an HVAC Contractor

          Choosing an HVAC contractor means comparing more than a system brand or a headline bid. Ask how the company assesses your home, prepares its technicians, documents the proposed work, communicates after installation, and handles service or warranty questions.

          Read The Guide
          Homeowner Guide

          How to Compare HVAC Estimates

          Two HVAC prices can cover different work. Compare the written scope, ductwork and equipment differences, available options, visit type, follow-up questions, and the answers each proposal provides before choosing based on the total.

          Read The Guide